Author Topic: Carb Starting point  (Read 3457 times)

Offline BBvetteDRVR

  • Garage guy
  • **
  • Posts: 9
Carb Starting point
« on: August 22, 2018, 07:31:41 PM »
Carb started dripping pretty good at idle and loading up when stopped at any lights.
Checked all the usual things (timing, vacuum leaks, etc) without finding anything obvious. Decided to pull the carb apart to see if anything jumped out. Carb was rebuilt 4 or 5 years ago

468 (454 +.030) with somewhere between 9 ~ 9-1/2 : 1
Automatic
comp cams hyd roller XR270HR),     .510 lift, dur 270/276
Short tube headers
69 GM aluminum intake, very low rise, has the hot slot but the intake/head gaskets are blocked off.
3 gasket sandwich on the base

71042216
78/48b CM
Idle tubes .044
Down channel .050
upper air bleed .069
lower air bleed .077
idle bypass air .139
idle mix screw holes .079

everything nice and clean, all passages clear

Idle has never been spectacular but could usually get it down to 650-700 in gear but not now that it's dripping
Points with B26 van, usually on manifold vacuum
15" (bounces) vacuum at idle

Fuel pressure was at about 8-ish at idle (bouncing around from 7 to off the scale of this old snap-on vacuum / fuel pressure gage) and smoothed out to a solid 7 when the engine revs up a bit

I bought an adjustable fuel pressure regulator but haven't installed it yet.

Idle adjustment screws at at 2-1/2 turns and do cause the engine to stumble and slow down if I bring them in to about 1 turn or less.
@-1/2 turns seems about the highest vacuum reading, any more doesn't really change it (still bouncing but around 15")



Going to re-assemble the carb tomorrow and re-install. Looking for any guidance at all to help trouble shooting in a logical sequence
Thanks
B


Offline Cliff Ruggles

  • Administrator
  • Qjet Hero
  • *****
  • Posts: 5432
Re: Carb Starting point
« Reply #1 on: August 23, 2018, 05:10:12 AM »
8psi fuel pressure is fine with that carb, assuming it's a 7040216.

Pretty small cam for a 454 build and tight LSA with early closing intake.  I've tuned a few Chevy engines using those cams and all exhibited "quirky" idle quality, especially the Big Blocks.

I see the same symptoms with their "famous" XE camshafts, and attribute some of the problems to slamming the valves down pretty hard and bouncing them on the seats, or at least that's what the engines act like and there was some associated valve train noise with them similar to having Rhoads lifters installed.

Not a fan of any of their camshafts, flat or roller and they leave BUTT LOADS of power on the table if you are using the "shelf" grinds.

I attached a copy of some dyno sheets from a 455 Pontiac engine, nothing exotic, just a simple 455 engine build with factory cast iron heads and 9.3 to 1 compression.  Comp suggested the XR276HR cam, it didn't make the grade anyplace and the customer noted "quirky" idle quality and EVERYONE at the dyno shop blamed the Q-jet for the engine being such a "turd".

When I was contacted about it, I quickly moved away from the Q-jet "bashing" they were throwing at me and asked about cam specs, compression and head flow.  I told them to throw the XR276HR cam in the dumpster behind the shop and gave them specs for a custom ground HR cam instead.

I had them grind it on a 114LSA with the ICL set at 110 degrees. 

Not only did the new cam make a BUTTLOAD more power at every RPM, the engine builder noted that the "quirky" idle characteristics disappeared and the engine actually idled nearly dead smooth with the larger cam on a wider LSA.

Enough cam bashing, but for sure for what you are doing I'd give me a call at some point.  If you aren't getting fantastic idle quality with a TON of initial timing with the timing off the scale and some nozzle drip changes are in order for sure.......Cliff

Offline BBvetteDRVR

  • Garage guy
  • **
  • Posts: 9
Re: Carb Starting point
« Reply #2 on: August 23, 2018, 06:57:27 AM »
It wasn't the greatest cam choice by any means but I was trying to make everything more for boulevard crawling and I this was my best guess at a hyd roller. I did (and forgot to mention) go for a set of 1.72 ratio rockers for an insignificant increase in the lift.

The timing was set to 36 total (vac adv disconnected) at about 2600
16 at idle (vac adv disconnected) at 850ish

When you say "...If you aren't getting fantastic idle quality with a TON of initial timing with the timing off the scale and some nozzle drip changes are in order for sure"

What kind of timing numbers are you suggesting? I was thinking of maybe 18-20 initial would be lots, I could monkey with the vac-advance and try to stop it at 38-40.

I've finished checking everything on the carb and started putting it back together, anything I should note/check or change before I do?

Thanks again for looking this over
B

Offline 77cruiser

  • Qjet Hero
  • *****
  • Posts: 628
Re: Carb Starting point
« Reply #3 on: August 23, 2018, 11:39:38 AM »
Have you tried lowering the float a bit?
Jim

Offline BBvetteDRVR

  • Garage guy
  • **
  • Posts: 9
Re: Carb Starting point
« Reply #4 on: August 23, 2018, 01:24:29 PM »
It's already down a little. It was about .350 I actually move it up closer to .3+

Carb is back together and installed, now just to decide on where to begin re-timing the engine and start the adjustment process again.
B

Offline 77cruiser

  • Qjet Hero
  • *****
  • Posts: 628
Re: Carb Starting point
« Reply #5 on: August 23, 2018, 03:11:04 PM »
Did you check TDC to make sure the damper is right?
Jim

Offline BBvetteDRVR

  • Garage guy
  • **
  • Posts: 9
Re: Carb Starting point
« Reply #6 on: August 23, 2018, 06:29:33 PM »
Damper is still fairly new but the reference line from the outer ring to the hub I put on is still correct so unless I sheared the key...

Keep the ideas coming, I'm going to start it and work through the timing tomorrow
B

Offline Cliff Ruggles

  • Administrator
  • Qjet Hero
  • *****
  • Posts: 5432
Re: Carb Starting point
« Reply #7 on: August 24, 2018, 05:27:55 AM »
Initial timing should end up around 10-12 degrees for most builds.  This will insure easy restarts when it's fully warmed up and heat soaked.  For a well thought out engine build you should be making PLENTY of vacuum at idle without having to add any more timing.

If the engine isn't pretty happy around those numbers then the engine compression ratio is too low for the cam choice.

When you get a moment wonder over to my thread in the Lobby on camshafts:

https://cliffshighperformance.com/simplemachinesforum/index.php/topic,3650.0.html

Enough on camshafts.  The Big Block Chevy emission years Q-jets had TONS of idle bypass air because those engines had pathetically low compression ratios and crappy camshafts.  I've heard they were even retarded some to help get them thru emissions but have never actually verified that.

What I do know is that a big block Chevy 454 in any configuration is a "sleeping giant", and all that you need to do is tighten up the squish and put a much better camshaft in it and they will absolutely ROCK your World.

Small camshafts on tight LSA's aren't going to make the grade in that arena.  They don't have enough seat timing for the big displacement and close the intake valve way too early.  Just look at the dyno sheets above and you can see what happens when you put a long duration cam in a big engine with much wider LSA and later intake closing.

The wide LSA really spreads out the power curve and gives them a fighting chance to make the big power they should be making.

I've had scores of engines brought in here to tune, some from great distances, and not one single time have I been the first bit impressed with any of them when the builder used a relatively small cam in them on a 110 or tighter LSA. 

Even with all that said you have to tune for best results.  If the engine wants/needs more timing and fuel at idle speed then you have to give it to them.  Tight LSA also causes "reversion" (my terminology for the shootty/quirky idle we often see from them and the fact we have to add more fuel/timing to make them happy at low RPM's). 

So bottom line the carb has to be set up to provide adequate fuel at idle speed to keep it completely on the idle system and good sensitivity/control with the mixture screws.  Adding idle fuel will also help off idle, transition and put more fuel to the engine in the "normal" driving range via the transfer slots. 

From what I've seen here 48B rods are too fat unless you are using the APT system in the baseplate and can get them up out of the jets some. 

I use a different jet/rod combination for the Big Block carbs with the huge MAB's and have had perfect success with them.  I also use our orange power piston spring as it is a clone of the same spring used in the 350/350hp and 454 and 427 high output engines.

The big block carb also requires the high flow N/S assembly and I'd use our HP accl pump in it........Cliff

Offline BBvetteDRVR

  • Garage guy
  • **
  • Posts: 9
Re: Carb Starting point
« Reply #8 on: August 24, 2018, 08:45:04 AM »
No APT on this carb
Setting the carb up now, vac-advance off and plugged, timing with no vac advance at 35@ 2400 gives me 20@950 I'm going to wire the weights closed to see but it looks like the mech advance is coming in right away. Using the gold springs from the aftermarket kit
M

Offline BBvetteDRVR

  • Garage guy
  • **
  • Posts: 9
Re: Carb Starting point
« Reply #9 on: August 24, 2018, 09:34:38 AM »
Got the idle down to 800 in park but it's not happy when the car goes into drive, 850 is about the limit where it'll still sit in drive and not feel like it's going to quit.
14-15" of vacuum at idle
Vac-advance connected to ported (Tee with the line going to the charcoal can like the factory did)
Still dribbling gas out the driver side nozzle, not as bad as it was but still doing it.

Installed the pressure regulator and dropped the pressure to 5psi with no effect other than the pressure is steady at idle instead of pulsating

So I'm looking at everything again
When I adjust the idle screw (solenoid in my case), that pushes opens the bottom plates some and in my case I guess it opens them too far and it starts sucking more air past the nozzles and drawing the gas out.

If I hook the vac-advance to manifold the rpm at idle shoots up past 1000 so I should be able to back the idle solenoid off and let the plates close more which should reduce the air being drawn down (if I'm even remotely understanding what's happening) and possibly stop the drip?

Will having the vac-adv puling all the time hurt anything else?
B

Offline 77cruiser

  • Qjet Hero
  • *****
  • Posts: 628
Re: Carb Starting point
« Reply #10 on: August 25, 2018, 05:48:18 AM »
I run manifold vacuum on mine, I have it limited to about 10 deg. if I remember right.
Jim

Offline BBvetteDRVR

  • Garage guy
  • **
  • Posts: 9
Re: Carb Starting point
« Reply #11 on: September 03, 2018, 01:51:45 PM »
Still working on it but vacation is over.

piston is a little sticky in the bore so might not be pulling down, polished the bore and re-assembled so hopefully I can try sometime this week
M


Offline Cliff Ruggles

  • Administrator
  • Qjet Hero
  • *****
  • Posts: 5432
Re: Carb Starting point
« Reply #12 on: September 04, 2018, 04:10:54 AM »
Yes, there is APT on that carb, it is located in the baseplate between the mixture screws.  They can be stubborn to get loose, but if you can remove it we make an external APT screw for them.

Not sure why you are trying to employ so much mechanical timing with light distributor springs.  I've NEVER had any luck with that deal using aftermarket kits.  There is always some of the mechanical curve in at low rpms causing idle issues and huge drops in RPM's when the trans is placed in gear.......Cliff

Offline BBvetteDRVR

  • Garage guy
  • **
  • Posts: 9
Re: Carb Starting point
« Reply #13 on: September 04, 2018, 05:38:53 PM »
Ah, that (APT) it's been epoxied over

I switched back to a set of heavy springs on the mech advance to try to stabilize the idle more. Is slightly better but still seems to stutter. Drip seems much better but still there and the idle won't improve.

I've gone through the ignition wires with a meter and they seem fine but I'm going to pull the whole distributor and drop in another one and a set of wires to test.
The one in there is the original and other than shimming the end-play and new points/condenser/rotor and cap I've never really gone through it.

Hopefully if I can stabilize the idle it'll be enough to idle down that little bit more I think I need.

Offline Cliff Ruggles

  • Administrator
  • Qjet Hero
  • *****
  • Posts: 5432
Re: Carb Starting point
« Reply #14 on: September 06, 2018, 02:36:44 AM »
NOTHING good happens with idle tuning until the ignition timing is rock solid and not adding any timing below about 900-1000 RPM's.

I fight this battle on a daily basis as a high percentage of folks looking for carb help also have distributor issues caused by well meaning attempts to establish a super-quick timing curve.  For some reason that approach has been associated with "high performance" since way back in the 1970's when I first got into this hobby.

If you want sparkling throttle response and super quick engine power then choose the engine parameters wisely.  Folks make poor choices, too much cam, LSA too tight, lowering compression for pump gas, etc, then find out their new engine idles poorly, soggy off idle and lacking in efficiency in the "normal" driving range.  So they go after the timing curve to offset the negatives imposed from less than ideal engine parameters. 

I've been seeing this for decades now, and not complaining, as it's brought a LOT of work in my direction!

Anyhow, keep working on the tune, I'm sure you'll get it nailed down.....Cliff